Call us : (888) 830-0219
Paragon Place at Bishops Bay
5240 Bishops Bay Parkway |  Phone: (888) 830-0219

Paragon Place Apartments represents the very best that the Middleton, Wisconsin, area luxury apartment living has to offer. Our pet friendly community is located in the highly desirable Watermark neighborhood in the Community of Bishops Bay and represents a desirable combination of modern amenities, sophisticated style and remarkable value, featured in one and two bedroom apartment styles.

Whether you’re catching an early morning or after hours workout in our state-of-the-art 24 hour Fitness Center, meeting a friend for coffee and enjoying all the modern conveniences of our Paragon Perk Internet Cafe´, or catching the game and shooting billiards with friends in The Clubhouse, Paragon Place at Bishops Bay is designed with your active, healthy and social lifestyle in mind.

Middleton, an award winning community and recurrent favorite on CNN Money Magazine’s Best Places to Live, has ranked within the Top 10 on the coveted list for four years running. Centrally located within the Madison Metropolitan area, Paragon Place is just 6 miles northwest of the Wisconsin State Capital and the University of Wisconsin Madison. You’re also just minutes away from numerous attractions including the State Street Shopping and Dining District, Greenway Station, Monona Terrace, Overture Center, Pheasant Branch Conservancy, the new Splash Park and over 70 restaurants and other cultural offerings. All this, coupled with an easy commute to the downtown business district and east and west side employment centers, and it’s no surprise why people are proud to call top ranking Middleton their home.

We invite you to contact us today for more information and to schedule a private showing.

Floor Plans

Experience the exceptional attention to detail and design that only Paragon Place at the Community at Bishops Bay in Middleton, Wisconsin can deliver. Our collection of spacious, open-concept one and two bedroom floor plans range in size from 775-1386 square feet.

Enjoy exclusive golf course and park views, open-concept kitchens featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, plank floors, Kohler gooseneck faucets and top-of-the-line finishes. Abundant walk-in closets, private washer and dryer, oversized bedrooms and living rooms, near floor-to-ceiling windows, expansive patios/balconies and more! Some apartments also boast cathedral ceilings, tray ceilings, fireplace, and in-unit storage areas. (See apartment unit plans for specific in-unit features.)

Monthly rental rates include, one parking space, exclusive use of all on-site amenities, water, sewer, trash removal, and indoor bike storage. Please inquire within for bike storage availability.

One bedroom deposit is $500
Two bedroom deposit is $750

Call us today for rental prices and to reserve your apartment today!

Floor plan images are for illustrative purposes only.  Square footage, floor plan, room dimensions and amenities may vary from those shown here.  Pricing and availability are subject to change.



Community Amenities

  • Clubhouse with Billiards, Darts, Bar & Lounge
  • 24-hour Internet Cafe & Coffee Bar with Free Wi-Fi
  • Pool with firepit and lounge area
  • Outdoor patio with firepit, grilling station and food preparation area
  • 24-hour Fitness Center
  • Free Weights
  • On-Site Management
  • On-Site Maintenance
  • Elevator
  • Recycling
  • Bike Racks
  • Controlled Access Lobby
  • Rentable storage lockers
  • Smoke Free Community
  • Close to Restaurants and Shopping
  • Bike Trails
  • Heated Underground Parking


  • Open concept kitchen, some featuring granite and some with quartz counter tops, stainless steel appliances and Kohler gooseneck faucet
  • Private washer & dryer
  • Expansive private patio or balcony
  • Solid core bedroom and bathroom doors
  • Cable Ready
  • Electronic Thermostat
  • Central air conditioning
  • Window Coverings
  • Oversized & walk-in closets
  • Disposal
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Carpeting
  • Plank Floors
  • Ceiling Fan
  • Exclusive golf course & park views
  • Fireplace in some apartments
  • Cathedral and tray ceilings in some apartments
  • Kohler Gooseneck Faucets
  • Stainless Steel Appliances

Pet Policy

Pets - allowed
Cats - 2 allowed Deposit $500.00,
  • Restrictions: 1st floor: Max. 2 dogs, 1 dog and 1 cat or 2 cats. 2nd floor: Max. 1 dog, 1 dog and 1 cat or 2 cats. 3rd floor: Pet free zone.

Dogs - 2 allowed Deposit $500.00,
  • Restrictions: 1st floor: Max. 2 dogs, 1 dog and 1 cat or 2 cats. 2nd floor: Max. 1 dog, 1 dog and 1 cat or 2 cats. 3rd floor: Pet free zone

Office Hours


Our Location


Paragon Place at Bishops Bay
5240 Bishops Bay Parkway 
Middleton, WI 53597
(888) 830-0219